KryptonSean

You can actually tell. If the commentary says "____ will feel that was harsh", or "____ will have a real claim for a penalty there...", or "that looked dubious". Obviously, with commentary off than there is no way of knowing.

For me:
-Superkeepers Don't exist
-Superstrikers (Jermaine Defoe )
-unnatural player ability, especially in regards to dribbling and shooting I know where you're coming from with dribling
-No set PA, I'd like a PA which is dependent on how the players perform. They do this in SI's (I think it's SI's) baseball game, but for some reason it's not in WSM. For instance, if a player is consistently playing well and demonstrating potential, then his PA (and CA) should go up. If Messi, for example, starts playing horribly, his CA and PA should go down. Sorry, no. It just doesn't work. Obviously CA is in the flux but PA shouldn't be, that's the whole point! Imagine a game where you could sign any player and he'd get good with no effort, it would be boring! </BLOCKQUOTE>

Other stuff: Elano isn't over-rated, the game bumps up his stats for some reason.

Team talks are one of the best parts of the game.

retired_lanice2001

Get rid of the damned team talks. They annoy the hell out of me cause the emphasis placed on them can be so much.

retired_mekeesha

Get rid? You think this doesn't happen in real life? It's a hugely important part of a manager's job. Yet again, the problem isn't it's existence but it's implementation. It needs improving.

retired_flippitt

The skin is awful on the game.

Also, there are 2 news screens - would be alot better if there was one to get all the news on.

retired_swany20

Sure it happens but not like in FM. The manager doesnt just say one sentence and the team then decides weather to win or lose the game.

The main problem with them is that they add nothing to the game but some unneeded micromanagement. They are not fun, the implementation is seriously flawed and no better implementation is possible until we can have human level AI. Then we would just speak into the microphone and the AI would decide how to react. So i say remove them for the next 50+ years until the technology catches up.

retired_lanice2001

Yeah, exactly.

Sometimes the teamtalk is just like a lottery. Tell them the wrong thing and it's an excuse for the game to compel a loss upon you.

deantibbetts

Surely that isn't reason to get rid of it though. If it was done properly and didn't afect it so dramatically then it would be fine and you probably wouldn't want rid of it.

retired_SnJ

i actually disagree and say that superkeepers do exist and it has nothing to do with tactics. how cn you claim that my tactics are the cause of a goalie saving every one on one and long shot thats bullsh** and ignorance. its obviously that goalie is having a VERY good game but the difference is they have a good game wayyyyy to much. i understand that some goalies are actually that good but when i have so many chances its hard to believe that they could possibly make so many saves and cost me a match.

anyway in relation to the topic i doubt there is anything that need to be removed most things just need to be changed and everything the same.

what i think needs to be changed is that league news. the league news should only include match details and league specific things e.g. goal of the month but i think that goal of the month ect should be sent to our inboxes as well. all transfer news should also be sent to our inboxes and not to the league news because i never know who my ivals have bought half the time unless i luckily get take to the league news and happen to see the headline.

deantibbetts

I'll start by saying, that I mean no offence in the following statements and hope you can take it as constructive criticism rather than ignorance (unfortunately the nature of these forums means I feel I need to sy this).

Well firstly, I bolded that section because I just don't believe you and think you have exaggerated in an attempt to try and force your opinion across as fact, when all it's really done is make your super keepers argument rather flippant and redundant.

As for the whole superkeepers argument, it's been discussed to death on these forums and there are as many people who don't experience it as do experience it. The fact that users don't ever encounter a "superkeeper" and score plenty of goals in relation to their chances would surely prove that the people encountering it are doing something wrong.

retired_SnJ

i have nop problems scoring. its not like evry keeper is stopping me from winning i just think some keepers are way too good on the game it is only against certain opposition that i struggle to beat their keeper so that is why i adamant that it is not my tactic but that individual such as romas goal keeper and pepe reina in my eyes they are super and i can bet that when you play against them you struggle to score also its just maybe you dnt notice it as much as some because i happen to play against those goalies on numerous occassions.