If you register for free, you will be able to post threads, vote on polls and lots more. If you have problems with the registration or logging in, please contact the administrator.
i do like the 2D match day pitch but it takes away things like how good the goals were and stuff, the thing is.. if they made it 3D then it would be to similiar to fifa and PES and they would have to concentrate to much on getting the graphics right..
what do you think?
The amount of bugs that were on the 2D match engine this year was far too much too handle, and changing to a 3D engine would be taking the game forward far too quickly.
I say get the 2D match engine perfect before even thinking of switching to a 3D match engine.
The amount of bugs that were on the 2D match engine this year was far too much too handle, and changing to a 3D engine would be taking the game forward far too quickly.
I say get the 2D match engine perfect before even thinking of switching to a 3D match engine.
The amount of bugs that were on the 2D match engine this year was far too much too handle, and changing to a 3D engine would be taking the game forward far too quickly.
I say get the 2D match engine perfect before even thinking of switching to a 3D match engine.
far too quickly??? this is not the nasa space program, we had 2d for four years....time for a change
Look at LMA and fifa manager - these are two crystal clear reasons why 3D match engines would not be a good idea.
A ridiculous number of animations would be required to do all of the things the 2D match engine does without looking silly - and any 3D engine can only have a finite number.
I mean, if the new PES can't get it right (with all their experience), how do you think SI are going to?
And yes, they probably would spend too much time on getting the graphics right.
wow this is a real good discussion lol i dunno really in my opinion i dont care there are plus's for both
+ i really want to be able to see the spectacular goals
- i dont want it looking rubbish though
maybe after a good goal is scored they can take all the players away just on the screen and all you can see i a 3D version of where the ball was hit and where it went into the goal but leave out the players (maybe just focus on the keepers and the ball ?
that would be cool as it would be a good compromise
I want to see my little dots running around in 2D so I can watch the whole match at a higher speed.
But I would like to see the highlights in 3D, seeing that overhead bicycle kick or you player lobbing the keeper would add a huge dimension.
knowing why the keeper just seemed to lie there and not move after saving a shot, only for a player much further away to run over and tap it in would also be clear. I shouldn't have to guess (imagine) that he is lying down, or on his knees and can't get there in time.
The 2D engine is still the best way to view a full match in my opinion.
3D matches would be bugger, repetative and spec intensive. I don't want to have to update my computer to handle a feature that at the moment won't add any enjoyment. Sure it would be cool to see a goal here and there to begin with, but when you've seen the same thing hundreds of times...or the same bug as the 3D graphics and match engine match up....you'll soon grow tired of it.
I like the 2D match engine. I love it in fact, I think it gets across a great deal of information and the 08 version looks a lot more organic than any previously. I can live without seeing it all in 3D, I have an imagination and I'm not afraid to use it
FM09 should they change this ? 
Linear Mode
