gubbs

Offsides.

Watch replay.

Clearly not offside.

State so.

Get told 'video shows ref was right'.

Whats the POINT?

Even when you are right, the game says you are wrong.

lucky326

I've been right once. Reply was the FA was being unusally Silent and that TV replays had proved that I had been correct.

megafan2005

ive learnt to be a 100% right ive got numerous touchline bans from my time at Aberdeen in the SPL its probably best to keep your mouth shut

SWaRFeGa

I'm correct plenty of times.
Doesn't make any difference though, you won't get the goal given the day after.
Seems like you're the one who is wrong if the "video shows ref was right".

Jimboola

No point disageeing with offsides or appealing bans. However right you are...you are always in error. It is quite pathetic that such a thing is in the game if it doesn't mean jack.

Nice ideas, not followed through I am afraid.

MaD_WeeGiE

I find i dont get much luck in appealing or not agreeing with decisions against me. Then again but when u see that option to complain... and if ur worked up.. u just cant help but click it lol

glamdring

I never appeal red cards and only very rarely (when I'm totally incensed and lose my marbles completely) bother to question a referee's decision. The absolute best that can happen is one player has a morale boost because you spoke your mind - on the flip side that self same player could think you have stirred up controversy (seems pretty random which of those two happens) and you get all the usual stuff of warnings, fines, touchline bans etc.

LukeVanBishop

I hardly ever bother replying, unless I get the sour grapes option in a derby...but you can hardly be wrong if you look at the commentary rather than watching the replay.

JoeyKbd

I know exactly what you mean! I think the feature is good and realistic though, becuase if the decision was wrong and you complain and are right, what do you expect is going to happen? Nothing would happen in real life. And if your wrong in your criticism your going to get a warning or fined or whatever, so the best bet is to really keep your mouth shut, although I have been right a good bit in my complaints, its not impossible.

mattymcl

My big gob has landed me a few touchline bans,so i tend not to reply anymore.

If its an offside decision ,i will usually check the replays to see if its close enough to call,and respond accordingly.

Its the fouls and red cards that get me punished,as you cant really tell one way or the other.

I would like to see, perhaps in a future version of the game, an option that when you check the replays after a disputed offside, the replay would stop at the moment the key pass is made. Saving a lot of time trying to stop the replay at exact moment the pass is made.