retired_galapogos

I found this defender in Treviso and i bought him for 200k. His name is Federico Ziliotto. I found out that his PA is 198 but right now his stats aren't that great. His CA is 105. Here is his profile:
http://img231.imageshack.us/img231/5...iliottofz1.jpg

Can you guys give me your opinion on whether i should keep him or sell him?

retired_donnandkids

definitely worth keeping and having out on loan.


cant see what benefit you could get from selling him

retired_pandora

You will sell him to me for 2M wont you?

retired_pandora

One more thing you should loan him in Italy to have the Home Grown status but it's too late. He's already 20.

retired_kellymhkr

what on earth do you mean by "loan him in italy to have HG status"... Why does it matter where he loans him.


He looks great for a young defender but looks like he will have some weaknesses. He won't be the strongest defender in the air. Bravery is a tad low but then again if you say he's has such a high PA then I would think all his stats are going to go up up up.

You'd better give him some game whether on loan or in your first team otherwise he may not reach his potential

retired_Lcord

Certain competitions in Europe have minimum quotas whereby you have to reach "Minimum [x] players trained in [x country]" or "Minimum [x] players trained by [your team]". I'm not sure whether it would apply in this scenario because he's Italian anyway - I don't know the exact criteria.

BuckyBadger

He's at Everton.. so the HG thing doesn't mean anything unless he plays for an Italian team.

retired_galapogos

Got a bid from Arsenal for 1m and a 2m buy-back clause.
Also one from Milan for 1m and 45% of next transfer fee.
Should i sell him? I would prefer selling to Milan but Arsenal have a buy-back clause...

retired_janae55

If you don't need the money then keep him. Or you can sell him to Arsenal and then buy him back when he becomes worldclass

retired_galapogos

I don't really need the money but i wouldn't mind selling him if he couldn't make the first team.

Can someone post a screenshot of him in the future?