Robbo#

Never trusted coach reports. I think I was put off when I saw one on my 34 yr old DRC: 'His best years are still ahead of him'.

mark g

My 20 yr old SC was banging in the goals in the reserves, but was too young for 1st team football (according to the "experts" . What the hell, i thought, as i'd been tempted to play him for 18 months. He averages over 7 and a goal every other game (and there's now no mention that he's too young, by the way!).

Robbo#

I've never had a lot of variation either like someone else said. They all say the same thing in my experience. But maybe that's 'cos they're all crap.

arbitrary

I bet if you get your coaches to give you a report on the same player now, they'll probably love him.

I tend to ignore my coaches unless they are agreeing with me

Taipan

The only coach I might listen to is the rare one who isn't a sheep like the others and speaks his mind. Three will give shining reports, while this black sheep cans the player for being lazy etc.

Rare breed, but they are out there.

shawng1

I always make those my assistant managers. That is, assuming they have the ratings to support their outspoken opinions, that is.

jraldous

<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><font size="-1">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by Flecky:
I had a corker recently...

I started scouting the opposition, and when he returned with one of the clubs, he made a comment about how they are a good side, despite their lowly league position.

The opposition were top of the league at the time. <HR></BLOCKQUOTE>

Now that's a LL scout to be proud of!!

B.A. Baracus

Listen, you can't blame the fella for getting on the wrong train, happens to all of us.

Bryce Barnes

In the LLM online game, I had my coach scout next opposition, in this case Bell's Southend side. He came back and advised that Bell's centre forward was one to watch, who would pounce on any chances that fell his way. The guy scored 1 goal all season

Robbo#

<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><font size="-1">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by Robbo the First:
Never trusted coach reports. I think I was put off when I saw one on my 34 yr old DRC: 'His best years are still ahead of him'.<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>

There was an article featuring this player only yesterday...he's playing for Farnborough against the Arse. Looks like my coach was right, although he is actually only 26 IRL.