NepentheZ

I'm not sure if this should be in the suggestions section. Guess we'll find out.

Overall best eleven is great. I love the feature. But a would love to see a history of EVERY player who played for the club in your management, and only the games they played under your management.

E.G

Player A - 2009-2013 - 130 Games, 65 Goals, 32 Assists, 7 MotM
Player B - 2010-2025 - 645 Games, 179 Goals, 344 Assists, 80 MotM

an so on.

Only When the player retires/leaves the club does he get inducted into the history, but i would REALLLLLLLLY love to see this included.

Any thoughtS?

aaberdeenn

I certainly like the idea of having a history of every player who played under your management.

I don't however like this idea. I prefer the ongoing all time best 11 where players are added into and dropped out of at the end of every season.

rinso

yeah, would be good to see the history of everyone you've manages at the club... :thup:

isuckatfm

:thup:

Great idea, especially for those who play really long term games. Unfotunately my laptop is such that I doubt I will get past 2030 on FM 08.

But it did remind of playing CM 01/02 to 2080 and wishing I could look at some of my previous legends stats beyond those where they appeared in the club records.

NepentheZ

The main reason i would like this feature.

Another reason is because I'd like to see the massive MISSES the club has had.

E.G

Player X - 2010-2017 - 12 Games, 0 Goals, 1 Assist, 0 MotM

What a waste of 7 years

aaberdeenn

Would this reflect every player that is under your management as a whole or the club you are currently managing?

Maybe this could be broken down into something like this:

All time.
Previous Clubs.
Current Club.
International Team.

NepentheZ

I think perhaps that, or in the history section just...


Player F - Burnley (2009-2013) - Games 120, Goals 4, Assists 7, MotM 23
Player G - Real Madrid (2015-2018) - Games 79, Goals 54, Assists 34, MotM 40

aaberdeenn

Well yeh just like that but I thought it might work more effectively if you could filter it down into sub-areas.

Good idea though and I'd like some representation of this included in the next version. :thup:

Jimbokav1971

My username should really have been Statto.

I LOVE stats.

It's my favourite saying, (or seems to be anyway), but SI introduced an excellent new feature in "best eleven", but did so VERY poorly.

1. The stats included are only for the years that individual players were vited into the annual best eleven. So if a player was in it for 3 years and then not in it for the next couple of years, although he would be in the "overall best eleven", his stats would only show 3 years worth of figures.

2. If you can do club "best eleven", why can't you do "competition best eleven". We could have all-time Premiership best eleven or all-time FA Cup best eleven.

3. From there we go onto competition stats. You have record all-time goal-scorers at International level for nations, you have record all-time goal-scorers for clubs, you have many awards for seasonal top scorers in various competitions. Why then can't we have All-time Premiership top scorer. Or how about most FA Cup appearances. All stats that are available in the game should be on a rolling basis as an all-time record.

The David James clean sheet record.
The Gary Speed Premiership appearance record.
The Alan Shearer Premiership goals record, (is it even him that has it?).
The most International goals record.

All this information is in the game already and it's just a matter of getting it stored and accessible in such a way that it doesn't slow the game down.

I love the "best eleven" feature, but it could and should have been so much more.

4. Stats in general. We can't see tackles and pass % for non-competetive games. This drives me flippin mental .

5. I want statistical data on what part of the pitch goals are scored from.

6. I want statistical data as to what time during a game goals are scored and conceded at.

7. In an ideal World, the best eleven feature would only be updated when a player either left your club or retired. You would then be able to click on the player and see not his attributes but his playing stats and accolades. How many medals and trophies he won. Hom many game she playedm goals/assists/MOM awards/clean sheets he got.

You put something so innovative in like "best eleven" but then really don't do it justice. It's a real shame.

Jimbokav1971

The just was bolded because I know it is no little thing I am asking. It didn't read like that though when I read it back.

Sorry.