You are 100% correct in most reguards.The simple fact that i get sooooooo ****ed of when i loose a game that I should have won, is really the reason we play this isnt it.For me its the feeling that u have acheived something.Guess what! So do rl managers.Kudos to si for making it more realistic..But that wont stop me from being ****ed at my boys for giving a 2 goal lead away.Tactics win games.Yes so do star players.but remember this, this game is a simulation of rl events. If u want total control over what a football team does, go play fifa on ur xbox and create a team.Only way ur ever gunna be getting what u really wat.But finnaly though on a sour note..I freekin hate super keepers..lol..but i can deal with it.they only come round every now and then