Why are you after Ashley Young or Giles Barnes? If you want a right winger you have a great one in Walcott. Those two are not any better than Theo and you can retrain this kid into an awesome AMR. With his pace he'll always get past his man and put in a good cross. Also, Ashley Young is better on the left. You could make a cheeky enquiry into Wright-Phillips. He's good too (unlike real life!).
GK - Yeah Preston is a good one. Turning out well in my current Arsenal game. If you want someone who can play immediately, try Robert Green. He's much better than Robinson.
CM - Agree with others. Michael Johnson if you want someone English. You might want to sign Jose Baxter for the future too. Turns out brilliant. Lee Cattermole & Mark Noble are two other possible targets.
Buffon - he would cost you more than 50M mate. He loves Juventus and they love him. So dont expect anything close to a decent price on him. He's valued at over 20M so you can nearly triple that before you could hope to land him. I was fooling around in another game and tried to sign him. After a lot of negotiation, the lowest I got it down to was 78M! But that was just a game where I was finding my feet in FM08.
Totti - no, not worth it. He too would cost you more than 30M.
Henry - yep. I got him back in one save in season 2. He's happy to come as he hardly plays for Barca sadly. I got him for as low as 14M. But you should be able to land him for anything between 14-22M. Well worth it as he'll give you atleast 3 more years at his best. I got him and he scored a hat-trick against Man Utd in the Community Shield - his first match back!!
Dean Ashton is decent too. He's very consistent for sure but I wouldnt sign him. He's out of contract in season 3 and if he doesnt sign a new one, I'll probably consider it. But not otherwise. If you're happy going for a BRITISH player rather than only English, you could look at Kevin Doyle. Good player.
Other potential English players you can look at are:
- Michael Mancienne, Jack Hobbs, Nedum Onuoha, Steven Taylor for your defence. You could look to get Fabrice Muamba back from B'ham. He turns out into a good DM.
- Jose Baxter, Scott Sinclair, Michael Woods, Andy Carroll, Daniel Sturridge & James Vaughan for your midfield/attack.