You could try playing defensive on the counter attack. The obvious result is you'll have a lot less chances, but they *should* be better quality (mainly the ones on counter attack) and scoring 1 from 5 is a better ratio then 1 from 25.
It should also lessen the chance of getting that last minute suckerpunch and losing 1-0 thanks to their only shot in the game.
On the flipside, you might get battered and lose 2-0 thanks to their 20 shots on target

(in which case your tactic isnt working, or your players cant cope with the oppositions' pressure)