retired_Stan21261

Just now when asked to comment on controversial fouls we tend to just sit on the fence as we only have the commentary to go on.
How about for televised matches when we click the view incident button, the screen is magnified greatly on top of the incident? Therefore, you can see the two players, the ball and the normal 2D view with the players collideing etc. be it with the fouler playing the ball first then the man or vice versa.

This would only work for matches that are televised though as the idea would be that the magnified view you are seeing is the slow motion replays from TV.
This would make replying to controversial incidents worthwhile.
I believe that this would work as you are asked to comment way after the match (your inbox), so in reality you would have plenty of time to see the incident.


Thoughts?

retired_mssa007

Personally I'd just prefer a 3rd party opinion of the incident. Currently you only have Team A saying "it's not a penalty", and Team B saying "it is a penalty". So who is right?
Better to have a quote from a leading pundit, such as "In my book, that has to go down as a penalty"