If you register for free, you will be able to post threads, vote on polls and lots more. If you have problems with the registration or logging in, please contact the administrator.
Although replays did seem to indicate the ref amde the correct decision
When you complain about pens given against your team or "goals" your team scores only for them to be disallowed for offside has anyone ever had any response apart from the fact that you were wrong and the officals right?
Obviously for pens you cannot tell anything from the view incident but I have a few offsides were the replay clearly shows my guy to be onside but I still get the same response
01-09-2008, 12:15 PM
Although replays did seem to indicate the ref amde the correct decision Post #2
Originally posted by VonBlade:
Yes you can get a "The FA have remained quiet and replays have shown the ref made a mistake".
But it is rare. And with a top down 2d blob it's nearly impossible to tell decisions.
Really :eek: I obvisouly have not played enough
Still if this response exists I think it should be more common as we all know how many poor decisions (as refs do a dificult job and the game is very fast etc before some qualified comes on here and slates me) there are every week IRL
As I said obviously you cannot tell for pens from the 2D view incident replay but for offsides by slowing down the speed it is easy to tell if it was right or not and it is annoying when you told the decision was right when you can clearly see it was wrong
01-09-2008, 12:22 PM
Although replays did seem to indicate the ref amde the correct decision Post #4
no point making a comment about fouls at all, but i watch the replays in slow motion and comment whenever it is offside. i have recieved the message VonBlade mentioned, but i'm not sure it adds anything to your manager profile, for example.
01-09-2008, 12:24 PM
Although replays did seem to indicate the ref amde the correct decision Post #5
I find that with offside rulings it is pretty easy to see if they are offside or not and generally the game knows as well and will agree. I normally only get my touchline bans from penalty decisions. The only guess I can make with penalties is whether the player stays on the ground after the challenge. If so I usually give it a try, but have rarely seen it go in my favour.
Offsides = easy
Penalties = impossible
01-09-2008, 12:30 PM
Although replays did seem to indicate the ref amde the correct decision Post #6
Originally posted by Klimowicz:
no point making a comment about fouls at all, but i watch the replays in slow motion and comment whenever it is offside. i have recieved the message VonBlade mentioned, but i'm not sure it adds anything to your manager profile, for example.
I have stopped commenting for fouls but then one of my players (who had given away the pen) got upset because I didn't defend him
I am not bothered about my profile but want to keep my players happy. I have just complained about an obviously onside goal we scored that was given offside and 3 of players are happy that I speak my mind.
I do not understand why if there is a feature in the game that says the decision was wrong you do see it when the replay clearly shows the decision to be wrong
01-09-2008, 12:34 PM
Although replays did seem to indicate the ref amde the correct decision Post #7
Originally posted by Abaddon879:
I find that with offside rulings it is pretty easy to see if they are offside or not and generally the game knows as well and will agree. I normally only get my touchline bans from penalty decisions. The only guess I can make with penalties is whether the player stays on the ground after the challenge. If so I usually give it a try, but have rarely seen it go in my favour.
Offsides = easy
Penalties = impossible
Thinking about it now maybe this could be an area where your assistant or coaches have more involvement in the game and insted of watching a replay (which you probably saw before anyway!) you could get a list of opions from your staff as to whether it was or wasn't a pen?
01-09-2008, 12:37 PM
Although replays did seem to indicate the ref amde the correct decision Post #8
i suppose that the club/player loyalty rating can only increase if you defend players like that, but then when you get a touchline ban, the board aren't impressed and you could lose you job over time. but surely if you increase a players opinion of you, you'll get better understanding of tactics and performance levels...
its win/lose, but i can't say i've had to do it much.
01-09-2008, 01:17 PM
Although replays did seem to indicate the ref amde the correct decision Post #9
On my current save I had a game last season where I goal was disallowed for offside. The player was clearly onside (and by some distance), so of course I complained and the news item said that replays showed the goal to be offside. I'll try and dig it out, because the testing/bugs team might like to have a look at it.
01-09-2008, 01:35 PM
Although replays did seem to indicate the ref amde the correct decision Post #10
just a minute ago the opposition won with an offside goal so i complained having seen the replay and it being offside. but i got a touchline ban!
WHAT THE FUDGE
Although replays did seem to indicate the ref amde the correct decision 
Linear Mode
