wrote loads and the server went down lol..
still at work but cant write it again, but...
your team settings are a tad extreme, the tempo, width, closing down, and time wasting seem to high for me, most of us set a min/max lvl of about 6-15 on most etc width...
the manual says that time wasting to early can be bad, try setting it to 10..high closing down and tempo can tire your players fast, is fatigue a problem late on? i'd say below 70% you want to look at subbing..
erm...others...your passing is 1 = one touch football, only the top teams can do this, try setting it at top lvl of short, also manual suggests matching passing and tempo, i'm guessing you have a lot of chances but miss the majority due to a hurried shot, try a lower tempo..
holding a lead..lower mentality to say normal, lower width, take fwr off fullbacks, raise timewasting if on rarely, maybe tick counter attacking..with that formation try pulling wingers back to the ML/R positions,so you have more of a diamond..
btw, i'd play commons at AMC, prutton is fine for the CM engine room but is technically crap! commons is a much better playmaker. bastians is pants but he'll do a job until you can get a better AML (try going for lee martin, out of contract soon in my game)
thats all i got time for, and its a bit random but if you need more help gimme a shout