FM7.
FM8 unpatched: workarounds ok but every direct free kick goes in. Drove me nuts.
FM8 Beta: Worse. Every clear run to the edge of the penalty area results in a goal through a keeper apparently composed of thin air if it's on target. Defenders mysteriously run away from the attacking player. Throw-ins go to straight to opposition strikers who stroke the ball home from the edge of the area through a composed-of-thin-air keeper. Goalkeeper distribution still a portent for an opposition one-on-one. Grey non-league teams from hell, etc.
I could re-intstall and play patchless, but FM7 just seems more attractive.