Thanks for that, Tom.
I'll elaborate on what Quinny said:
In LLM the idea is learn everything for yourself. If someone signs a promising player he wants to find out for himself whether he will live up to expectations, not be told he does or doesn't.
Much as the laws of cricket have a preface imploring players to play within the spirit of the game as well as within the laws, LLM should also be played (and discussed) wihin the spirit implied by the guidelines, not just to the letter of the law.
I'm not trying to have a go at you, just elaborating on why your post elicited a 'FFS'.