I got feed up with this game so I cheated and did the following to see how the game would react to a team of 11 200 PA/CA players that I controlled.
I tried tactics that I downloaded and default 442 to see how the game would react.
The players where inconsistent to say the least, you would think 11 x 200 CA players would roll through all comers no matter what tactic but you would be wrong.
Then I figured well lets make all the 11 players have perfect stats, which I did with the aid of a memory editor, again, they where inconsistent.
Now ignoring that I cheated to have the best 11 players in the world, it clearly showed to me that there is problems such as:
1) No matter how good your team is, tactics overrides everything!
2) The game favors the AI.
This is one of only two ways I can think of testing whether the game cheats or not, and
imo, there is something seriously wrong with this game. I did the same in fm06, 05 and one of the earlier cm's, guess what? they had no problems winning, but why do they have problem in 07? Clearly there is a problem.
I did this to test the game, so I had to cheat, but anyway I am sure someone will tell me I deserved to lose

.