Miles, thank you for the post! As you may have read in the previous thread, SI is like a "family" to me so I really appreciate your trying to explain and clarify the situation.
But I would still like to point out, without ever attacking you or being a dick, that the closing down bug isn't fixed as of the latest beta patch. Tested it with MU, Rangers, Nott Forest, Verona and Schalke using a standard 4-4-2 tactic with
PRESET individual instructions for each position (i.e. those that were created by you) most of the time. Of course, I tried tweaking the instructions (mostly changing man marking to zonal and vise versa). What I'm trying to say, is that I tested the game with as less extreme tactic as possible. Everything standard.
The results have been poor... Not sure how it compares with the unpatched version, but the bug is certainly there.
Another issue I've been eager to point out for quite a long time now is... I'll try to explain.
Most of the time, when a player is in a good position to pass the ball and his teammate is almost certain to score, he doesn't pass the ball. Instead, he shoots. From awkward positions. The most basic example is when you have two strikers on one GK and the striker with the ball has to just pass the ball to the other stiker, who will be facing an open goal and just has to tap the ball in. But in FM stikers rarely, if ever, do that. Instead they shoot. From very very awkward positions and angles. Same thing with wingers and any other players. And it has nothing to do with tactics, because it's been there since FM 07 (or maybe earlier) and I've used hundreds of tactics and instructions. This is just one weird thing... Nothing major, but sometimes it's just unreal how they refuse to pass the ball.
Cheers Miles! Good luck and please
TAKE YOUR TIME with the patch! I'm sure all sensible fans would rather wait than get a patch that'll require a new patch to patch it
We want the bugs sorted. Period. Again, I'm sure we'd all rather wait and have them 100% totally sorted than get the patch early next week and still swear profoundly after seeing the bugs alive and breathing.