Jason84

Who are some players in 08 whose performance/attributes are noticeably better than what they are in real life and/or valuation in the game? Every year it seems like the people at SI rate a few players too highly for some reason or another.

One example that comes to mind is Kevin Doyle. Granted he's a solid striker but in this year's game I think he'd probably be in the top 5% of strikers. Another is Eddie Johnson. Even w/ 0 mental stats he's still a good player every year in FM and cheap.

Gorgonzola

Andrea Barzagli is well over-rated in this game!

BlackCats Rule

not sure in 08 but in 07 billy sharp im sure was over rated he was like 25+ goals per season in the prem, im sure if he was that good he'd be in the prem in real life ?

diegowong

mark noble is very underrated in the game. cementing a place in the U21s and West ham IRL and cant even play better than nigel quashie in the game.

jonahno6

Matt Derbyshire is underrated

raiden131313

imo agbonlahor is underrated, granted they game him extreme speed but i think his technical is a lot better than what it says, imo he should have around the same stats as ashley young