retired_julienew1212

Who are some players in 08 whose performance/attributes are noticeably better than what they are in real life and/or valuation in the game? Every year it seems like the people at SI rate a few players too highly for some reason or another.

One example that comes to mind is Kevin Doyle. Granted he's a solid striker but in this year's game I think he'd probably be in the top 5% of strikers. Another is Eddie Johnson. Even w/ 0 mental stats he's still a good player every year in FM and cheap.

retired_crislyn

Andrea Barzagli is well over-rated in this game!

retired_mistyminnew1212

not sure in 08 but in 07 billy sharp im sure was over rated he was like 25+ goals per season in the prem, im sure if he was that good he'd be in the prem in real life ?

retired_mikizoro

mark noble is very underrated in the game. cementing a place in the U21s and West ham IRL and cant even play better than nigel quashie in the game.

retired_hockeymom2

Matt Derbyshire is underrated

retired_shortstop21

imo agbonlahor is underrated, granted they game him extreme speed but i think his technical is a lot better than what it says, imo he should have around the same stats as ashley young