Cindarella

I thought that maybe we can have some sort of system when we comment on stuff, it's only a suggestion, though.

Background:
Render:
Effects:
Positive points:
Less positive points:
Other:

I understand if you think this would be bad or something like that but as I said, it's only a suggestion.

adobe

well the idea is nice,man,but not everybody has time to do it,i mean they are 6 things that we have to comment on a sig,and a lotta time and nerves goes for only one sig,after that everyone will start to cry 'cus no one will comment on their sigs..i think that system will even decrease the number of comments..

retired_txar215

nice idea but I don't think that many people would write all that like Wnnrssn said most people won't have time to do it. But if someone wants he can give comments like that, there's no specified commenting style. Only one word posts like good, wow, nice are not very welcomed here.

Darren

id just like people to comment on threads that havent any replies instead of lookin in one with 5-6 comments and echo what others have said

adobe

182,u just can "say" to someone what to comment..if it's a low class sig most of the people don't comment it because they are lazy,on a low class sig there a many things that can be improved and a comment on a sig like that takes too long,got it?On the other hand on a sig from a expirienced designer u say only "It's great,fantastic colours,render is beautiful and the background is awesome,u should make a tut for that" and that's all..BUT as like i said not everyone has time to comment..

retired_srs1018

That's nonsense Wnnrssn, it's a public secret that people only like to comment on the good pieces that they like, instead of giving critism on 'bad' artworks. That's just the mentality on most people here now-a-days.

adobe

well from one side people don't have time to comment,on other people like to comment the best works,that's my opinion.. i don't quite get ya but whatever..

chica1985

That is pretty much true mate, but I dont think we should have a policy on how we comment (Poffeman) cause it would make it more boring and there would probs be less comments, also not everyone would think of using this while replying to graphics.
Yea i know people have a hump over the lack of comments but thats life, shit happens. People have freedom to post on what Graphic they want we/they do what we/they want, you'd do well to think you can have a balance from the good, the bad and the ugly Graphics. People Comment on Graphics that are good and/or on the content, like the team they support etc. I see lack of comments can be a catalyst to a better graphical performance cause you know if you arent getting many comments, make some shit stuff and the comments will seep in. Thats how I think of it and do it

DebDeb

I'd much rather comment on a piece that appeals to my artistic nature, because with a 'bad' piece, its always "The text needs improvement, working on cutting." etc.