russianlul

If you remember last year, i tried to start a tactical comparison guide form the tactics that was sent to my by people around the forums. I was managed to run it successfully for a period of time, but later i struggled because of the lack of time. This year i am back with lots of free time and determination to test your tactics.

Until the time of full version release i will test your tactic with Newcastle United squad. After the release, i will start testing it with another team which i haven’t decided yet.

Tactics will be tested on following circumstances;

##each tactic will be tested for 10 games from the same save game.
##after the test is finished, i will be posting a .rar file, which will include the tactic itself, and proof of statistics (screenshots) i will be posting.
##Statistics will include:win / lose / draw percentages
goals for / goals against (total&per game)
possession per game
shots on/off target (total&per game)
total position of the tactic among other ones.
##later today i will be posting a .rar file which includes, pictures of the attributes of my players, fixtures of the ten games that we will be playing.
##i will ask you to send me your tactic along with the squad selection you want me to make.

Well, thats it for now.

If there is any other statistics the you’ll be interested in seeing on the table please let me know until i get to home and start taking screenshots.

Until night, take care...

retired_elpata

I'm interested to know what this proves or what your aiming to do?

russianlul

i guess this will reduce the number of threads asking "what is the best tactic?" or "is there a cheat tactic?".

I am pretty sure that it will be good for you and rashidi, preventing you trying to find and lock this kind of threads.

It will also provide information about who created most succesful tactic in forums under given conditions. people will try to be number one.

i know that 10 games is not enough but t will definetely provide some info to people who are not patient.

retired_scriler

I think the people who don't know why 6 for closeing down is better or worse than 8 for closing down on the slider system, will flock to a thread like this.

russianlul

thats a good point, because not everyone plays the game too seriuously. some just play the game to satisfy ther ego by being succesful in the game. my aim is that..

retired_kellyk

My thoughts..sorry but I have a software to launch, I'm very busy and my time on the forums is limited...thought I'd give you a heads up...

1. Tactics are affected by a lot of other things

2. Running a new tactic at the start of the season and in the last 10 games have a different effect

3. You can't use the Assman because its inefficient, he doesn't behave in a consistent way

4. Even if you were to reduce all the variables the game has evolved from what it used to be like in the past. The style of play has changed...you can drop tempol reduce width for other effects and some tactics are designed to do that.

I for one don't mind closing threads where they don't post enough information, and I don't want to see you get bad feedback as well cos it may lead to mismanaged expectations.

retired_kellyk

essentially you going to get a lot of people who don't know tactics flocking here cos they think the tactics are legitmised as good..when in reality I don't think the thread will be able to achieve that.

retired_elpata

I still don't see the point, this thread will not eliminate all the other threads that appear. All that will happen is you will be feeding the 'noobs' egos by claiming there tactics are good/bad based on a 10 game play by you.

Why do people feel the need to test tactics? A tactic is supposed to be created for a certain user for a certain game etc. If people want there tactics testing then they will ask so in there thread.

I'm sorry but threads like this are not welcome nor helpful in the slightest as they ar very misleading and cause more rifts than anything else.

retired_Hurky

send you my tactic to your e-mail

thanx for testing

russianlul

thanks to feedback i received from cleon and rashidi i have decided to cancel the test as i don't see any points in doing something that is thought as useless by the moderators of these forums.

i just wanted to make something to help people who are asking for a good tactic or i search of a base tactic.

anyway Golden_Team i will try your tactic in my own games and i'll let you know the outcomes...