Arthur Boruc --- The most overrated keeper ever!

retired_markmo · 11-06-2007, 12:08 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Number 7:
Artur Boruc is one of the best keepers in Europe, I've been a Celtic Park season ticket holder for 10 seasons and hes been the best goalkeeper in my time! Hes miles better than Craig Gordon, who ALSO made mistake after mistake in the SPL (e.g The one he PUNCHED the ball into his own net from 2 yards after a Jarosik header against Celtic). He could go for around £10m - £15m to either Milan or Arsenal.

Would this be the same Boruc that has cost Celtic points a few times already this season? Remember the Hibs game?

I think that Boruc & Gordon are of a very similar high level. I just wish that Celtic fans would lay off him for that one mistake. I think that both keepers are rated about right in FM :thup:

retired_crislyn · 11-06-2007, 12:12 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by jonahno6:
Dida > Boruc
valdes > Boruc
Boruc > lehmann /almunia

Dida better than Boruc!!!
are you out of your mind!!!
last time i saw dida he was awful and all the milan supporters hated him

retired_abermea1441 · 11-06-2007, 01:04 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Stylish Kid In The Riot:
<BLOCKQUOTE>Originally posted by Number 7:
Artur Boruc is one of the best keepers in Europe, I've been a Celtic Park season ticket holder for 10 seasons and hes been the best goalkeeper in my time! Hes miles better than Craig Gordon, who ALSO made mistake after mistake in the SPL (e.g The one he PUNCHED the ball into his own net from 2 yards after a Jarosik header against Celtic). He could go for around £10m - £15m to either Milan or Arsenal.

Would this be the same Boruc that has cost Celtic points a few times already this season? Remember the Hibs game?

I think that Boruc & Gordon are of a very similar high level. I just wish that Celtic fans would lay off him for that one mistake. I think that both keepers are rated about right in FM :thup: </BLOCKQUOTE>

Is the correct answer.

retired_specialksl · 11-06-2007, 01:50 AM

Too many jealous buns on here by the looks of it..Yeh hes over-rated and the European Champions are constantly linked with him. He will leave one day to one of the biggest clubs in europe FACT!! he'll go for about 9million could be more.

retired_enthused2lose · 11-06-2007, 02:04 AM

boruc is world class end off,what does it matter what league your in when your a keeper anyway.the epl is well over rated anyway you have 4 good teams the rest are all very average,as for celtic would struggle in epl look at these results blackburn 0 celtic 2 celtic 1 blackburn 0 celtic 1 man utd 0 liverpool 0 celtic 2 thats 4 games in europe against english no goals against and 4 wins.as for the *** who says rangers getting a draw against barca is a better result than us beating the european champs your having a laugh.

retired_kagilfilen · 11-06-2007, 03:52 AM

Im just laughing at the idiots that are trying to say "average" english teams are better than celtic. I mean..in all honesty...tottenham are s**t. Do you think they could beat milan at home? They really fail drastically sometimes in europe. Sames as everton ect. Except they have done well this season.

Also, we are all aware of celtics "poor" away record in the champions league. As i said before...we are jinxed in the CL. Something happens that mess up our players. God knows what it is but it aint because we suck. Watch, i bet we beat Benfica and Shaktar (who?) lol at home.

We seem to do well in the UEFA Cup. We reached the final not that long ago and almost won it. Fair enough the whole team has changed since then but i do recall us BEATING and KNOCKING OUT barcelona over 2 legs...come on, tell me rangers draw is better than that?

Celtic are one of the BEST teams in Europe and Boruc is one of the BEST keepers in Europe.

Enough of this bull to be honest.

retired_rflynn0005 · 11-06-2007, 06:19 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by bertsquall1:
Does anyone think he is well overated in the game. In IRL hes only an average keeper but in FM i feel he is way overrated

I just feel that he's a fantastic keeper for Celtic, to be fair he has his fair share of howlers, but not as gaffe as Robinson's.

IF he starts to really concentrate and reduce his howlers and put in performances like the one he produced against AC Milan last year in CPL at the San Siro, then I feel there's no reason why he can't be up there with the best

ShaneFrost1 · 11-06-2007, 08:06 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by celtic_fc:
bertsquall, the SPL isn't the best of leagues but craig gordon made his name in the spl and was considered world class, despite no european experience he became the 3rd most expensive gk in the world when he joined Sunderland. IMO Boruc is as good if not better than Gordon and has proven it time and time again in the champions league. When boruc leaves celtic he will command an even greater transfer fee than gordon.

You contradict yourself when saying boruc isn't world class because he only plays in the SPL yet use the example of Craig Gordon, who established himself and became world class whilst playing in the SPL.

You say he would be found out if he moved, i'm pretty sure he would have been found out by now playing in the champions league the last few years against the best strikers in europe.

well said mate and i agree offcourse :thup:

retired_fajer · 11-06-2007, 10:40 AM

i am a celtic fan he is a tremendous keeper 2 but in the game he just a bit Over rated

retired_bhar105584 · 11-06-2007, 10:51 AM

Quote:

LOL. You serious. Name one top club that Boruc has played for...oh wait, he hasen't. At least Van Der Sar, Valdes and Dida have played for top European Clubs!

So because Boruc has'nt played for a "top" european club as you say, that means he is'nt any good? Were do you think VDS, Valdes, Dida etc all started from?

It's like saying that when Ronaldinho played for PSG he was S**T. Get a grip

Arthur Boruc --- The most overrated keeper ever!

Football Manager 2008 has a database compromising of tens of thousands of players.

Arthur Boruc --- The most overrated keeper ever!