retired_heidigoebel

We (the 'Boro) have a youth player who is on an acadamy contract which runs out at the seasons end, he so far hasnt and doesnt look like he will be signing a pro deal.

If he moves to another English coub then the compensation would be decided by a tribunal, but my question is what if he moved to a club abroad, would the club be entitled to compensation?

retired_lbherrera

I believe it would still be set by a tribunal.

retired_heidigoebel

Thats what im thinking, didnt arsenal have to pay peanuts for cesc?

retired_mickey5ca

Yes :cool:

retired_MikeMcC

im not sure, because Chris Porter ( used to play for Oldham ) moved to a scottish club at the end of last season and his new club didn't have to pay compensation ( despite him being under 24 ) because it wasnt in the country he was moving from.

retired_Frappin'

Is he any good?

retired_jnc021

by 'not signing' , do you mean he has been offered a deal and is refusing to sign it, or has not been offered a contract?

as i understand it, he can become a free agent first (at the end of his contract), and then move to another club without them having to pay any compensation, as he is not being taken from the team he leaves. not sure if this is strictly true or not, but i dont see how a club can be forced to pay any other if the player has already left, and therefore is not under contract to them anyway? however, if he has been offered a pro deal and is refusing to sign because he has been told he will be given a deal somewhere he might prefer to be, with or without having actually signed a contract with them, probably would result in compensation as the club would have been the factor in him not signing pro with you (if he was offered a deal)

retired_tillery.heather

Exactly the same thing happened at Crewe. Michael Higdon joined Falkirk on a free and they didn't have to pay compensation (not that he's worth any money).

Link to Crewe website: Gradi talking about 'loophole'

retired_heidigoebel

So its definatly a grey area.

The player in question has been offered a deal but has rejected it. He has been brought up at the club and is classed as home grown.

retired_Christian Ruiz

I thought you could pretty much get away with it if the player moved from another country.

Didn't Arsenal effectively hand over Van Bronckhorst to stop Barcelona reporting them to FIFA/UEFA?