retired_nini59

Just play

TK

Wes/Simpson
Rio
Vidic
Evra

Scholes
Ronaldo
Nani

Rooney
Tevez
Saha

please!

retired_carribear68

and Nick, by the sounds of it, I completely agree - they are morons.

Scholes and Giggs would be a disaster. Anderson slightly less so as he's a bit more active and energetic.

retired_bball3378

I'd actually go with Scholes plus Giggs/Anderson in the middle. You'd hope that Vidic and Rio will be able to do enough against a Heskeyless Wigan. Yes, it's a risk, but it's worthwhile under the circumstances (ie we don't have a natural quality holding midfielder available).

If you do need to go with an O'Shea or Pique as DM possibly chuck out Nani and go 433 with Ronaldo right up on the right.

Kookookachoo
Simpson/Pique
Vidic
Evra

Giggs
Scholes
O'Shea

Ronnie
Saha
Rooney

YZFRydn

Nope i didnt misread but added Giggs since you said play Sheasy because of his experience and that seems to be a Fergie thought on Giggs.

I'd always play a good young player with little experience over a crap player with bags of experience.

tbh i think its time O'Shea was moved on. I dont really see where he fits in anymore.

RB: Neville, Brown, Simpson, Pique
CB: Rio, Vida, Brown, Pique, Evans
LB: Evra, Evans, other kids
CM: Scholes, Hargreaves, Carrick, Fletcher, Anderson

Yeah we look short at left back but i'd rather the young kids like Evans got a chance there to bring them in to the first team than play O'Shea there.

YZFRydn

I also dont think Simpson is good enough to be starting at right back for us right now. People seem to have him on par with Evans in the talent stakes but he isnt at that level.

retired_carribear68

maybe I'm just forgetting how bad O'Shea is in midfield... he's too lovable to hate thats the problem.

dont think we should sell him either, possibly for similar reasons

runronnirun

not keen on that formation - those players in a 442 would be fine, 433 will just mean Giggs slowing everything down and playing as an extra Wigan defensive midfielder, and Saha being isolated up top.

442: TK; Wes/JOS, Vidic, Rio, Evra; Ronaldo, Pique, Scholes, Nani; Tevez, Rooney. i'd fancy that front two to cause Bramble/Boyce more problems than Saha on current form. although seeing as Saha has been called up for France, maybe we should make use of him while we still can...

retired_carribear68

look lets just agree that it's a blessing that at times like this, with selection problems in midfield, there is no way Fergie can resort to Richardson anymore \o/\o/\o/

retired_carribear68

I still think O'Shea is decent at fullback fwiw

retired_nini59

Nope i didnt misread but added Giggs since you said play Sheasy because of his experience and that seems to be a Fergie thought on Giggs.

I'd always play a good young player with little experience over a crap player with bags of experience.

tbh i think its time O'Shea was moved on. I dont really see where he fits in anymore.

RB: Neville, Brown, Simpson, Pique
CB: Rio, Vida, Brown, Pique, Evans
LB: Evra, Evans, other kids
CM: Scholes, Hargreaves, Carrick, Fletcher, Anderson

Yeah we look short at left back but i'd rather the young kids like Evans got a chance there to bring them in to the first team than play O'Shea there. </BLOCKQUOTE>

GK: Van Der Sar, Kuszczak, O'Shea

once Foster's back we can sell him.