If you register for free, you will be able to post threads, vote on polls and lots more. If you have problems with the registration or logging in, please contact the administrator.
It's a poor feature that's still waiting to work properly.
How the FA respond appears totally unrelated to the incident you can view. I've spent ages replaying an incident to see if a player was offside, come to a conclusion and then been told that TV replays say I was wrong - even though I'm not.
Red cards are even worse - since you rarely have any help on what you're supposed to say and viewing the replay doesn't indicate anything.
Basically all of the interaction - player, media, FA, board in this game is in dire need of an upgrade...but hey we got facegen, right, which adds so many levels!!!
yeah thats why i try to minimise my involvement in this side of the game, cause the consequences are so unpredictable - sometimes you think you are saying one thing but the game interprets it as something totally different!
Originally posted by Newky:
<BLOCKQUOTE>Originally posted by Lucho_:
The FA sometimes remains silent in the game.
What I don't understand is why would you ever complain about the ref. As in real life, it's not like they are going to change their decision after the match is over.
Maybe the game could punish refs that make lots of mistakes by making them work in a lower division in the next season, but that probably is too complicated for such a little improvement (unless it already does and I haven't payed attention).
It can get you on players favoured personel list
although it does depend on personality - some think you are right to speak your mind others think you should control your temper.
irl it gives the fans someone to vent their frustration on other than the team and their manager. </BLOCKQUOTE>
Not only that, the next game you get the same ref. Some of his decisions might come your way because u made some pressure on him. So yeah, if they make a mistake, a manager should be able to talk about that.
quote:
Originally posted by Lucho_:
The FA sometimes remains silent in the game.
What I don't understand is why would you ever complain about the ref. As in real life, it's not like they are going to change their decision after the match is over.
Maybe the game could punish refs that make lots of mistakes by making them work in a lower division in the next season, but that probably is too complicated for such a little improvement (unless it already does and I haven't payed attention).
It can get you on players favoured personel list
although it does depend on personality - some think you are right to speak your mind others think you should control your temper.
irl it gives the fans someone to vent their frustration on other than the team and their manager.
Not only that, the next game you get the same ref. Some of his decisions might come your way because u made some pressure on him. So yeah, if they make a mistake, a manager should be able to talk about that.
Is that a fact? Does the match engine actually consider that? I don't recall hearing about refs being affected by pressure, but it would be interesting if it works like that.
Originally posted by Tickers:
Basically all of the interaction - player, media, FA, board in this game is in dire need of an upgrade...but hey we got facegen, right, which adds so many levels!!!
Haha...... yeah too right. Who cares about fixing the game when I can (apparently) now watch my coaches face get older!
Originally posted by skinner05:
does anyone else hate the feature where you comment on a refereeing decision after a game.Not once after i have said the ref was wrong has it said that replays have shown the ref made the wrong decision.Its always the ref was right and then a warning from the FA.this has happened at least 50 times and not once the ref was wrong.realistic?? - i think not
You keep badmouthing the refs after every single match as a "professional" manager, with no evidence to back yourself up.
Originally posted by Rab1879:
that has nothing to do with this the simple fact we were cheated end off
it wasnt the refs fault you lost to georgia in the end italy got wat they deserved wich is a win and in the end scotland just couldnt complete there so called good run
Linear Mode
