Juddy !!

Sevilla was interested in vidic so i went to the sevilla team i saw alves was unhappy so i offered vidic for alves im just up to offering the contract now but is it the right move or not ? is alves really that good on this game or not ?

Chasing Lamely

DO NOT do it. Alves is pretty useless and struggles to stay fit. I bought him for Chelsea and he was fit for about 10 games all season. The rest of the time he was either injured or at about 79% fitness.

Ville Valo

Vidic is one of the best DCs in the game, you can get better DRs than Alves.

trollie

Alves is the Javier Zanetti of the old CM. Vidic is easily replaceable.. Depends on what you want.. but the immense number of quality stats on alves makes him ideal to cover the whole stretch of the right wing compared to vidic.

trollie

who can only cover DC/Sweeper.

Ched

what??? madness. Have used alves in several long and season long games, and in every one he has been exceptional. By far the best right back in the world. You can also play alves at rightwing (or even left back/left wing) if you have injuries, he has easily out played SWP at right wing when i've needed him there.

i used to use a formation using wing backs, and alves and ashley cole were the only things that allowed it to work.

As for vidic, he's good, but buy breno or the udinese defender (can't remember his bloody name, he's 20 and south american) both of them will usually become better than vidic and are already more than capable first team players.

Juddy !!

yeh i bought breno hes young but i dont think he would be playing good this early in his carrer

kennhyl

breno is a top class defender.

keep vidic and buy zaccardo - brilliant RB

SmurfDude

I sold Vidic and replaced him with Pique. Pique has the potential to be much better if you train him well.

dweaver

Alves is pretty unique for a FB. He can do almost everything great. Vidic is great, too, but there's a plethora of great CBs in the game.