retired_lina2212

what?????????? i am not sure what your getting at, but if you need to know what i am saying, then i again will say people who have been around such atrocities realise in a more intense manner than others the evils of murderers. i believe all humans should frown upon and scorn murderers


mute point tbh......i didn't say it is, i believe murderers shouldn't be given anything from the public.......

you guys do, different point, fact is however you are arguing my point extensively, in fact more so than your chagrin of murderers

retired_lina2212

i am saying you have too use emotions to decide the outcome of a murderers fate unless you post on OTF it seems

retired_mika318

i am saying you have too use emotions to decide the outcome of a murderers fate unless you post on OTF it seems </BLOCKQUOTE>

Fair is not an emotion. It is a decision you reach based on rational impartiality. It is not the result of two emotions balancing each other out.

shannon2007

You said, 'If I ever have my daughter murdered'.

Anyway, of course people should 'frown' upon all forms of criminality - thats why we punish criminals! Nevertheless, in a civilised society we must treat criminals humanely - however much that rankles. What makes YOU better than Ian Huntly if you condemn the guy (or indeed any other murderer/criminal) to death? What give YOU the right to kill?

retired_embartl

Why would you have your daughter murdered anyway?

And why is the fact Huntly is a child killer any more relevant to his health than if he had say, murdered his next door neighbour? </BLOCKQUOTE>

I just spat my drink out you bastard

retired_jesenia

oh god, what have you done BG

shannon2007

Sorry :p

And btw to answer thread title no, I personally would not give Ian Huntly a new liver. I need mine.

retired_lina2212

i beg too differ, we are not robots, emotion will override

I am not killing him, we messed his body up, he is in jail for killing children and not getting a nice 'diet' for his liver...

But i am condemning a man who killed 2 girls and has abused him body...........forgive me for condemning him

This isn't Sopranos, you know what i meant.

retired_lina2212

he*

retired_nini59

things we have learnt today:
Doog has never been murdered.
murder is bad.

things we are still not sure about:
how to use question marks and apostrophes.
whether child killers should get favours.
whether Mixitup will ever decide to have his daughter murdered.
whether 'fair' is an emotion.
whether child killers are 'disturbed'.
where the hell BG has gone, and where he even got this story from.


more questions than answers so far, at least we've clarified the most important things today though. Tomorrow we'll try and conquer even trickier questions such as "how old do kids have to be before you can kill them and still expect to keep your human rights?" (nelly thinks at least 12), and "even when life means life, for some people life is clearly not long enough, so how do we keep them alive even longer so that they can suffer until they've repaid their debt to society? and how long will this be in the case of Huntley? do we have enough livers for this?"