Jablome

I love Paul Scholes. He is one of the players that really got me into the Prem. He is incredible and has had a great career. My point is that dating back to last year, I see loss in his step. Not a lot, but enough that he is not at the top anymore.

So, best ever and now a little bit overrated. I don't think that is impossible. Some said that about Hyypia and I understand that.

Having said that, I do not think he is far past his best, just a little bit.

Bliss Seeker

1. Best Two: Gerrard and Cesc
2. Most Overrated Two: LAMPARD, LAMPARD AND LAMPARD
3. Most Underrated Two: Hamman and Cahill
4. Best Two of Alltime in the Prem: Keane and Vieira

mrmeee17

No, maybe it's because they afs.

Crazy_T

Best: Cesc Cesc Cesc
Overrated: Lampard
Underrated: Carrick/Xabi Alonso
Best Ever: Keane/Vieira
Potential: Lucas/Anderson

saved_by_barry_horne

best: Cesc, Essien
overrated: carrick, barton
underrated: parker, carsley
best two: vieira keane

Taz & The Devil

I love Paul Scholes. He is one of the players that really got me into the Prem. He is incredible and has had a great career. My point is that dating back to last year, I see loss in his step. Not a lot, but enough that he is not at the top anymore.

So, best ever and now a little bit overrated. I don't think that is impossible. Some said that about Hyypia and I understand that.

Having said that, I do not think he is far past his best, just a little bit. </BLOCKQUOTE>

You are kidding right? Last season he had his best season since 02/03. He was awsome and dictated games for Man Utd all season on their way to the title.

Scholes was rightly voted the third best player in the league. To compare him and Hyypia quite frankly a disgrace.

SuperStevieG

Best: Gerrard, Fabregas
Overrated: Lampard, Cahill
Underrated: Hamann, Barton
Best All-Time: Vieira, Keane

count blake

Cesc is class, Giles Barnes is pretty underrated

Jablome

I love Paul Scholes. He is one of the players that really got me into the Prem. He is incredible and has had a great career. My point is that dating back to last year, I see loss in his step. Not a lot, but enough that he is not at the top anymore.

So, best ever and now a little bit overrated. I don't think that is impossible. Some said that about Hyypia and I understand that.

Having said that, I do not think he is far past his best, just a little bit. </BLOCKQUOTE>

You are kidding right? Last season he had his best season since 02/03. He was awsome and dictated games for Man Utd all season on their way to the title.

Scholes was rightly voted the third best player in the league. To compare him and Hyypia quite frankly a disgrace. </BLOCKQUOTE>

And, this year? Prior to injury, he hasn't looked a tad slow? Or, perhaps it was a slow start.

Not comparing him to Hyypia b/c I used the them in the same sentence. Comparing the examples. Please.

Jonny "Kid" Pilko

Nicky Butt ifb.
Amdy Faye ifs.

There you go, all you need to know tbh.