[gavnoble]

Originally posted by Serpico:
So wrong Gav. Rose was one of the finest companions there's ever been. You just can't cope with the lovey-dovey aspects of it. Admit it.

Didn't say I didn't like Rose. Series One Rose was excellent, series 2 Rose was annoying - fault of the writers not the actress as Billie was excellent. I just prefer the character of Martha.

[gavnoble]

Originally posted by matt hudson:
Rose > Martha

But Martha's family is much less annoying

Only because they've hardly featured so far. And Rose's mum, well she'd get one from me...particularly the way she looked in the Love & Monsters episode from series two.

[matt hudson]

Pete was easily the best Tyler. So good they had to bring him back to life!

[gavnoble]

Statement on her fansite


I think the BBC statement is quite interesting as it does not discount the possibility that she was only ever going to be a one series companion.

[gavnoble]

Was about this time last year as well that the papers started again with the BIllie leaving Who stories and they were proved to be correct in the end.

[matt hudson]

Originally posted by gavnoble:
Statement on her fansite


I think the BBC statement is quite interesting as it does not discount the possibility that she was only ever going to be a one series companion.

From the fansite

:thup:

[matt hudson]

Obviously that should have been a quote. Wish I'd never got up today.

[matt hudson]

Anyway, hope Freema doesn't go as she plays a likeable character with a lot of potential and I don't see the sense in chopping and changing the lead roles.

[Sean Paul]

Come on :cool:

[Chaddy the Owl]

Paul McGann picture \0/\0/