[circlewalker]

Originally posted by Don Baker:
<BLOCKQUOTE>Originally posted by Ackter:
SI already have that forum with users like rashidi, Dave C and davidbowie helping out.

So, that's three GQ users. How does anyone else get involved in this forum? Are you suggesting that someone like Ceefax - who would make a valuable contribution to such a forum - has to post in GQ and put up with the vast number of stupid people in there before he can be allowed to give feedback based on his gaming experiences? </BLOCKQUOTE>

rashidi is T&T, Dave C is a researcher, davidbowie is a quite prominent in the FM07 OTF thread. Nick and BBB also tend to spend their time in this forum.

[retired_rockstar]

Doesn't offend me, does give a decent insight into you though. There are far better ways to express your frustration with constructive criticism being one of them.

And throughout that particular thread there is clear evidence that constructive criticism doesn't work - it's met with nothing more than your standard "it's your fault" answers. If one approach isn't working, I'm within my rights to take another.

[retired_Rynny]

Gregg saying exactly what i couldn't be arsed to type out :thup:

[retired_snsflip]

Originally posted by Ackter:
SI already have that forum with users like rashidi, Dave C and davidbowie helping out.

Any chance of a link to the forum?

Just had my goalkeeper go up for a corner in the last minute despite me winning 1-0. Was this bug not sorted last year?

[retired_Frappin']

Do you volunteer to be a tester or do SI decide who's made a good contribution?

[circlewalker]

Originally posted by foxmad:
Do you volunteer to be a tester or do SI decide who's made a good contribution?

SI choose.

[retired_rockstar]

And again - how do people get invited into that forum? Having not been in the OTF thread for a while, I can't say I've noticed davidbowie posting - and there are a lot more prominent people in that thread that I'd think would give good feedback.

Nick got involved in data because the United researcher was dire, and as a fan of the team and the game he offered his services. His issue was not with the way the game played, so I'd see that as a different thing altogether.

[retired_snsflip]

Originally posted by Ackter:
<BLOCKQUOTE>Originally posted by foxmad:
Do you volunteer to be a tester or do SI decide who's made a good contribution?

SI choose. </BLOCKQUOTE>
So should I take the fact that I've beta tested FM for the past 3 years and not been invited this year personally?

[circlewalker]

Originally posted by Don Baker:
<BLOCKQUOTE>Doesn't offend me, does give a decent insight into you though. There are far better ways to express your frustration with constructive criticism being one of them.

And throughout that particular thread there is clear evidence that constructive criticism doesn't work - it's met with nothing more than your standard "it's your fault" answers. If one approach isn't working, I'm within my rights to take another. </BLOCKQUOTE>

A quick search shows me that you've posted in 13 bugs forum threads since FM2005. A few of those are you just insulting someone. Very constructive.

Maybe if you vented your frustration towards the bugs forum then you'd feel a bit better about the whole thing.