shannon2007

Great idea, come on people it doesnt take much to vote!

retired_amyslack

Yes, come on peeps, exercise your democratic right and vote now. With so few votes received thus far it will slightly devalue the awards themselves (and increase the chances of ties and no money from bookie PM).

retired_sander

voted

retired_hunar_s

Right am busy tomorrow, but providing my game is cancelled on Sunday (and believe me, it will be... the weather is atrocious here), I will try and pick a few names and stories I recognise.

retired_hunar_s

Well I've just sent it... NOW!

retired_hunar_s

Oh one other thing... a 'complaint' you could say.

Now I'm not saying that Faramir doesn't deserve it, but isn't it quite strange how he's in the most under-rated grouping and writer of the year? Surely if he's in contention for writer of the year then he is rated?

Other than that, good work

shannon2007

Yeah its a point thats been noted Euan, and I agree there's no way Faramir is underrated, but that just shows hows daft the voters can be

Raptor

<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><font size="-1">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by Jambo_4eva:
Oh one other thing... a 'complaint' you could say.

Now I'm not saying that Faramir doesn't deserve it, but isn't it quite strange how he's in the most under-rated grouping and writer of the year? Surely if he's in contention for writer of the year then he is rated?

Other than that, good work <HR></BLOCKQUOTE>


I've made a provision for this: should Faramir be named Writer of the Year, he cannot win Most Underrated. All of this is caused by the curious nominations received in some categories. There will be a bit of fine-tuning next year.

retired_besheeran

The fact alone that he is nominated for Writer of the year means that he should be taken out of the most underrated category, unless you wish to imply that he is underrated if he gets anything less then Writer of the year...

BarryLFC

Agreed, a nomination for WotY is sufficient not to be "Underrated" IMO.