fetus

can you rate 1 being the highest to 10 being the lowest .

I give it a 5, sorry, but that's my honest opinion.

fetus

why dont you like it

I didn't say I don't like it, rating it 5 is me saying that this is an image that can be improved.

Earlier you posted a thread with the title "why?!", as if you were extremely surprised. Why were you?

There is no real focus. It could have been the eye, but it's pushed away too much to the side. The bright area in the middle is distracting and doesn't serve any real purpose.
I think it's also an unorganized mixture of techniques and objects without any real focus on what you're trying to express. Also the text feels a bit lost.

Just my view on it and I'm sure that there will be members with a different one.

MsOz

Sorry, but I can't even give it a 5 for average.
I don't like it at all. It's a 9 in my book, and that's only because I gave you a point for being brash enough to post it and expect high ratings.

The contrast is horrid, with the whites far too bright and the red/yelllow colors just making it worse.
The focus is bad.
The highlight in the eye is phony from a mile away.
The composition is nonexistant. There is no flow for the eye to follow.
The type is superfluous.
The background is at an angle dragging the eye off the page..
The brush strokes on the layer around the eyes look cheesy...

This honestly looks like you didn't take more than 5-10 minutes at most to create.
You'll have to put a LOT more effort into your work if you expect high marks from anyone with some art/graphics/Photoshop experience... [:I }P }

M-I-5

2, i realllllllly like it

Voting without coming up with arguments doesn't count M-I-5

fetus

i accidently did that other post, but i wasnt all surpirsed, different ppl different opions. ive posted on other forums where ppl love it. i just wanted to know if it was liked. the critisim helped but i wasnt aiming for a proffesional looking piece. thx for the comments though and m15 <3

MsOz

Were any of all those who reallllly liked it able to tell you why?

If not, they were probably of the "blanket praise patrol," who like almost everything people post...They're good for ego strokes, but you'll never learn or grow from their empty praise.

There's always a couple of 'em on every forum. M-I-5 proves that.

Well, I can't say I disagree with you MsOz.