Stella's 442
As stella predicted, this turned out to be a fairly solid tactic.
League Matches
-Pld----W----D----L----F----A----Pts----Pos
--23----7---11---5---27---27---32-----10th
Cup Games
J.Paint - 1st Rnd
League Cup - 1st Rnd
FA Cup - 1st Rnd
Stella seems to have come up trumps with this setup. I fully expected it to be better than the standard tactics, simply because of the inclusion of both individual and team instructions and it's proved that the good old 442 can produce results, contrary to those tests based on the 442 shape from earlier.
The tactic seemed to suffer a little from not scoring enough goals, resulting in a few too many draws, but it is (so far) the best defensively and conceded the least.
Tactic----------------Pld----W----D----L----F----A----Pts----Pos
532 Counter---------23----9----7----7---27---32---34-----11th
Stella's 442-------23----7---11----5---27---27---32-----10th
442 Normal----------23----7----4---12---25---39---25-----19th
532 Custom----------23----3----6---14---17---40---15-----23rd
433 Normal----------22----5----6---11---18---29---21-----Sacked
442 Diamond Att----21----3----6---12---19---43---15-----Sacked
451 Normal----------17----3----3---11---17---33---12-----Sacked
Thanks to
Stella for that one. I may well test it (and any others that seem to have promise) further some time later on.
Next up...
Thought I'd try out Timster/Mikedadude's "Enigma" tactic, since he and other players seem to be having some success with it. (Hope you don't mind Timster!

) Please see
this thread for details of the tactic.