adobe

Keep the expert opinions for yourself.I don't think critisizing Onskin's entry is really ethical.The final decision depends on the client.



Anyway,nice contest,great entry,Onskin,my man.

retired_aver

Onskin would appreciate that.

aadosx

im really sure he doesnt mind some C&C, but thanks for the attempted flame

retired_Monica

I'm quite sure he didn't post it up for C&C, at least not here anyway, and not from anyone but the client.

aadosx

ok you know what? thats swell and all. im so glad that you said that because i obviously cannot distingush these things for myself. am i right? i mean just because its the marketplace section doesnt mean i can give a suggestion? I already appraised Onskins' endeavor and expeditiously; I added in that it has blank space at the bottom of the post.

And did you notice that Wnnrssn already told me what you said (you = roark) and subsequently Nico21 the ADMIN posted and he didnt even comment on my remark.

And if the admin has no altercation towards my post, then I think no one else should comment on it.

Again, awsome job on the banner Onskin, wnnrssn i dont care if its ethical i said it anyways and everyone is still alive and well right? right. so buzz off, roark for future references 'dont start a fire once its already been put out'.

I DONT want this to be a flame thread so ill be the better person and refrain from visiting this thread again so im not compelled to respond to any dumbass remark someone makes. if anyone has a problem with me, PM. dont hi-jack the thread.

Let the contest continue and hope its a good one!

adobe

I am a moderator > 1.Admin 2.Moderator 3.You..

And it's not a dumbass remark,if you were on Onskin's place you would be really irritated.If you make something and you compete for a prize,you won't be the happiest person when someone says you've got any mistakes or something.Yes,nobody died,but nonetheless it's not ethical to critisize(even a bit)someone's entry.These are the rules of the forum.We've got a section for signatures,where you can critisize,and we have a marketplace,where the rules are different.And you've only got luck that i presume Horia didn't read your post,because as far as i know him,he would be on my side just by now.And don't tell me to buzz off,because you can buzz off for some days out of the forum.

retired_Monica

Could you not see that Wnnrssn apparently "couldn't" get through to you on the first run through? You had no right to react to Wnnrssn's post in the way that you did; you put no fire out. You came back with some smart ass, snide remark and left yourself open to it. For the sake of the competition (I can't see you not re-visiting the thread) however, I'll leave it at that. Have whatever say, wherever you'd like, I won't respond because apparently, you like the last word.

retired_kel

Stop it !!
Doesn't matter guys !!!
Let's not discuss it further

SomeSickSets

Wow... it looks like we almot got more posts due to the "flame" than for the competition itself

Anyway, I am pleased to announce the winner is...surpise surpise....

ONSKIN!

Your header is awesome bro! But next time, don't post so early hehehehehe

However I also would like to thank u all for participating! Your works were brilliant and measured up , but Onskin's was just wow...

Last but not least, I would also like to express my thanks to soccer art 's staff! Guys, your forum is amazing! Keep up the good work

Determined1

bravo