Meh

Please comment and/or criticize, but keep in mind:
This is my first ever sig and the first thing I have created with Photoshop which I only just got a few days ago, so please try not to be too harsh in the criticism. :o

~I made it with help from these tutorials by AC_Milan>*(and with lots of experimenting ):
http://www.soccer-art.co.uk/forums/s...ead.php?t=2407
http://www.soccer-art.co.uk/forums/s...ead.php?t=4629

aadosx

for a first. good job!

retired_Ark

Wow. Amazing for a first try.

2 problems I see: Background too bright (I don't like the whole shape of it either, but it doesn't mean it's bad) and that the render is too small. Make it about 1.5 times as big, and you'd have gold there.

Nice Try

Meh

Thank-you both!
^Thanks for pointing that out. Yay! I'm learning stuff!
Okay, so I'm working on enlarging the render and fixing the brightness of the background, but how would I go about making its shape better? What do you not like about it? Because I would really like to improve it.

retired_Ark

It's the whole flower thingie in the background. I just don't like it. It fits well with the sig, just that I don't like the style.

andygoon

I agree with Romanista4eva about the two things and I would add the red thingies could be used better. But for a first sig it's really good, keep on working and you'll progress

dudeman

I am noticing(sp?) a Kaka theme, anyways, I think it looks great it looks like he is grabing on to an angels halo

retired_Ark

"Nun me fare vedere De Rossi di nuovo, dio mio!"

hhaha...for those of u who cn't read Italian, "Don't make me see De Rossi again, my god!"

Meh

^^Cloudkicker09, yah im a fan .

Okay, after a few weeks of experimenting and lots of fixing up, this is my second try:


Anything I can fix?

I only had a few minutes a day to work on it, so it took a long time.
I went back and retraced the steps on the tutorials and I realized that I had made a lot of mstakes.
I followed the tutorial more closely this time, except I skipped the last few steps on the sig tutorial and just did something random.

It's not the best I can do since it's mainly an experiment, but I like it much better than the first.