adobe

.. at least for me,not the happiest person but i guess it's ok..

bill164

Love the render, but I think you could go a bit wilder generally with the style. I know you can do better but a damn good experiment still so well done. Please do work on the style because it's been too long since somebody has made something similar. Maybe next time grunge it up around the edges a bit, maybe have a thick border and erase a bit with a grunge brush or do the same with the text. Maybe even grunge up the render a little. Or the other way could be to make a completely new 1920's-style with ornamental brushes, clean bg with scraps of newspapers and wallpapers in strategic places. I think this style can go somewhere. Mind if I use this sig?

adobe

thanks for the great comment,dtunam,i will consider continuing the style..
sure you can use it

bill164

Thanks .

ToMeR-Lfc

listen wnnrssn, non of your sigs are shit... and defenitly not this one!! i think its awesome!! but i do agree with dtunam that you can do hell of alot better!!

retired_OLIM

nice sig man
not really any bad points imo
text fits well
bg is lovely
render goes nice too

chica1985

Form is temporary class is permanent

It's good but it's not great, I can see what you're trying to do. Use some textures to give it some more depth, like Paper and Wall Stocks to give it that real dirty feel. Thats the best way to obtain a grunge like look and using ornamental brushes would be good too. Depends if a vintage old style is your sorta thing, as you do a lot of modern original styles. This would look really good on a wall imo

adobe

^thanks,and you're correct..the problem is that i haven't used the grunge and textured look style much,i prefer the modern and stylish things in a sig,but i will try to change that.

retired_Victoriak

oh my days this sig is pure class. i luv that old look. it looks a bit of the tag you get with the utd shirt. everything is perfect

B.N.F.

You say on most of your sigs that are shit, but you get so much positive comments on them Its really a quite nice sig mate. The bg looks nice and original, but i think you can add something more to the left side and overal on the whole bg maybe. The text is really well put and fits fantastic with the bg, the render looks awesome to me and i think its the best part of the sig. Like Dtunam said you gotta continue this style